The Iran Ceasefire: Some positive signs but Lebanon remains an immediate obstacle
* The US and Iran agreed to a two-week ceasefire 90 minutes before Trump's deadline to destroy Iranian civilian infrastructure, brokered by Pakistan.
* There have already been ceasefire violations. Iran's Lavan Island refinery was struck, and it used this as justification for strikes against most Gulf states.
* Talks begin in Islamabad on Saturday April 11, with Vance leading the US delegation, which could help build Iranian trust in the process.
* The White House dismissed Iran's published 10-point plan as "fundamentally unserious", saying a subsequent unpublished proposal was the real basis for talks.
* Lebanon is the key short-term sticking point, with Israel insisting it is not part of the ceasefire, but Iran threatening to keep Hormuz closed while fighting there continues.
* However, the intensity of Israel’s assault on Lebanon today may be a sign that it anticipates that pressure will quickly grow for it to halt the war.
* The nuclear file may be the easiest to resolve, as there was already a framework from the February talks, but enrichment remains a stated red line for both sides.
* Iran’s demands for reparations and control of Hormuz aren’t viable, but could be traded for a lifting of sanctions.
* Oil dropped from $109 to ~$95 but remains elevated; it will take time for shippers and insurers to trust the ceasefire and, even then, physical shortages will persist for months.
Now read on...
Register to sample a report